Supreme Court Turns Down Bid To Revive Youth Climate Lawsuit

On Tuesday, the Supreme Court declined to revive a lawsuit brought by 21 youth activists who argue that the federal government’s energy policies violate their constitutional rights by exacerbating climate change.

The Court’s denial of the petition in Juliana v. United States represents a significant setback for the youth-led climate lawsuit. Filed in 2015 by the nonprofit law firm Our Children’s Trust, the case has faced numerous challenges in lower courts. The group contended that the 9th Circuit wrongly directed an Oregon federal judge to dismiss the case and sought the Supreme Court’s intervention to reinstate their claim, the Washington Examiner

After years of litigation, the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ordered the dismissal of the case in 2020. In May, a three-judge panel from the 9th Circuit upheld the dismissal, effectively halting the plaintiffs’ efforts to continue the case, the outlet added.

The Our Children’s Trust (OCT) website states that its mission is to secure “legal rights to a safe climate” for younger generations. Despite the Supreme Court’s decision, Julia Olson, the plaintiffs’ attorney, stressed that the fundamental issue remains unresolved.

“The standing of children to be heard in their right to life case is a pressing issue of national importance,” she told Reuters in a statement.

The youth plaintiffs may still request a review by the Supreme Court, with the deadline for filing a certiorari petition set for December 9. This step would enable the activists to present broader arguments on why their case should be heard and why they believe they have standing to sue the federal government over its climate policies.

In Juliana, the plaintiffs argued that the federal government knowingly pursued policies that exacerbate climate change, despite the well-documented dangers of relying on fossil fuels. However, the 9th Circuit ultimately ruled that the judiciary was not the appropriate branch to address such a broad and complex issue.

This lawsuit is part of a larger movement of climate litigation led by youth activists, with several cases across the nation in which plaintiffs seek to hold state and federal governments accountable for policies they argue contribute to climate change. While some youth-led climate cases have faced setbacks, others have seen progress.

For instance, in 2023, a Montana judge ruled that the state was violating the rights of young residents by blocking the consideration of climate impacts for new fossil fuel projects. Additionally, Hawaii reached a groundbreaking settlement this year to decarbonize its transportation system by 2045, noted the Examiner.

The Supreme Court on Tuesday declined to hear an appeal from John Nassif, a Florida man convicted for his involvement in the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol.

Nassif challenged the constitutionality of a law that bans “parading, picketing, and demonstrating” inside the Capitol, arguing it violates the First Amendment’s protections of free speech and assembly. The charge is one of the most frequently applied to defendants from the January 6 attack.

President-elect Donald Trump is considering pardons for many involved in the Capitol riot.

The defendant, 57, was sentenced to seven months in prison after being convicted of multiple misdemeanors, including disorderly conduct and violent entry. Prosecutors had initially recommended a sentence of 10 to 16 months, the Washington Examiner reported.

Related Posts

Bill Clinton with tears in their eyes make the sad announcement… – Check the comments 👇👇👇

Former President Bill Clinton, with tears in his eyes, stood before the cameras today to deliver a heartbreaking announcement that left the nation in shock. His voice…

I DELIVER PACKAGES ON THIS ROUTE EVERY DAY—BUT THIS DOG KNEW MY NAME BEFORE I EVER TOLD IT I’ve been working my UPS route in this neighborhood for over a year now. Same streets, same faces, same barking dogs behind fences. But this one blue heeler? He’s different. He started showing up about six weeks ago—just standing at the edge of a certain driveway, watching me. No barking, no growling. Just… staring. At first, I figured he was just curious, maybe someone’s new rescue. But every time I walked up with a package, he’d trot over and sit right at my feet. I’m not really a dog person, but something about him felt familiar. Like we’d met before, though I knew we hadn’t. Then one rainy Thursday, I knelt down to pet him. As I scratched behind his ears, I said, “Hey buddy, what’s your name?” And I swear to you—he tilted his head and let out this soft little whuff, then looked straight into my eyes like he was waiting. That’s when his tag slipped into view. It wasn’t the usual kind. No name. Just a tiny metal plate, and on it, stamped clear as day: “MILA.” That’s my name. I thought maybe someone in the neighborhood was messing with me. But the house he kept standing in front of? It’s been empty for over a year. Overgrown yard. No mail. Just a yellowed FOR SALE sign barely hanging on. I asked around, even checked the local shelter’s listings. No one had reported him missing. And today, when I showed up with a delivery two streets over—he was already there, tail wagging. This time, he had something in his mouth. (continue reading in the first cᴑmment)

I’ve been delivering packages in the same neighborhood for over a year—same houses, same routine. But then came Blue. Unlike other dogs, he didn’t bark or growl….

Robert Irwin, son of the late “Crocodile Hunter” star, posed in just boxer briefs, sparking a stir. 😳 Bold pics are in the comments.

Robert Irwin, son of the late Steve Irwin, is generating buzz with a bold new photoshoot for Bonds underwear, blending wildlife and fashion. The 21-year-old posed with…

😞 Last public photo of Kris Kristofferson comes to light and fans are in tears 💔😭 The pictures from his last public appearance of Kris Kristofferson have just emerged, leaving fans in shock. Check the comments to see the last photo👇

With Kris Kristofferson’s demise, a remarkable period has come to a close. He was not just a talented musician and composer, but also a poet who was…

Bill Clinton with tears in their eyes make the sad announcement…

Visibly distraught, former President Bill Clinton spoke to the media today about a heartbreaking announcement that left the country in shock. As he spoke, his voice wavered,

Dad Takes Drastic Measures to Teach Daughter a Lesson

A concerned father recently took to Reddit seeking advice on how to handle his 16-year-old daughter’s worsening attitude. He and his wife had noticed a drastic change…