13 True Stories That Get Creepier the More You Dig In

Not everyone needs to watch horror movies or read books to feel scared; they’ve had their own terrifying experiences. Some of these unusual occurrences have simple explanations, while others may make you question your perception of reality. One thing is certain: the true-life stories we’ve assembled will stick with you long after you’ve finished reading them.

Story 1:

My spouse texted me to say he’d be back from his work trip two days earlier. He came home on Monday and apologized for not warning me he was coming sooner. I asked, “What do you mean?” “I received your text!”
I showed him my phone, and we both became pale. A different message read: “Make sure to keep your phone next to you wherever you go; you never know who can mess with it!” We were so perplexed that we assumed it was a colleague pulling a prank. However, we discovered that the message had only been sent an hour before, and my husband was alone in his car at the time.

We still don’t know who sent those two messages, but thankfully we haven’t received any additional ones since.

Story 2:

After my cat of ten years died in December, I could still hear him meowing. Normally, I could dismiss it as simply thinking too much about him.

We had this ritual where we’d communicate back and forth—he’d meow, and I’d respond, “Clyde!” He would meow again, and I’d say, “Clyde!” Then he’d run up and we’d cuddle.

One day, I stepped outdoors and could hear him as if he were only ten feet away. Right after, I heard my own voice calling from afar, “Clyyyyde!” The meowing and my voice repeated themselves several times. It was really nerve-racking. When it came to a stop, I turned around and returned inside.
© Unknown author/Reddit

Story 3:

My husband passed away eight days before my daughter’s birth. My son was five years old at the time. He was 18 when I told a friend that my spouse never met our daughter. My son turned and said, “No, he actually did.”
The next thing he said made my spine quiver. He claimed that his father used to visit them at school every day for seven years, then abruptly stopped and they never saw him again.
What concerned me were the specifics my son recalled. He described the man—the red hat he wore, his gestures—as identical to what his father used to do.
I asked my daughter, and she described the same man, down to the last detail. It still makes me shudder because that man could not have been their father. He had already passed away. I still have no idea who the stranger that came to see my children was.

Story 4:

There was a girl who was madly in love with me, but I didn’t want to be with her. I didn’t think about her after school, but one summer when I returned home,

I discovered she had moved to my family’s building, to the apartment across from ours (my building has two flats on each floor).
I had never informed her where I lived before now. I decided to

be pleasant and talk to her family, greet the neighbors, and so on, and I learned from her mother that the girl had proposed they move there. Now,

I’m not sure if it was planned or by chance, but let’s just say we live in a big metropolis, so the chances of that being a coincidence were slim. © Kenhamef | Reddit

Related Posts

I Discovered the Real Reason My Son Was Struggling After Moving in With His Dad

When Mason decided to live with his father after the divorce, I tried to honor his choice, hoping the change would help rebuild the relationship he desperately…

For 12 Years, My Husband Took a Weeklong Vacation with His Family Without Me

For 12 years, my husband Michael went on the same vacation at the same time every year. One full week away. Same month. Same season. Same vague…

My Husband Asked Me through Tears to Be Mom to One of the Twins He Had with His Late Mistress

A Reddit user, a 29-year-old woman married to a 44-year-old pastor, shared a shocking revelation about her husband’s affair and the subsequent manipulation. He tearfully confessed to…

“MOM! LOOK!” my daughter screamed. I ran in to find finger-shaped bru/ises on my newborn

The room felt heavy with silence as Heather examined the photographs on the investigator’s tablet. My heart sank at her lack of surprise. It was as if…

My Parents Made Me Pay for My Own Meal While Covering My Siblings – They Never Expected My Perfect Payback

The night I got the text from Lauren about a “special family dinner,” I nearly choked on my instant noodles. It had been ages since we’d all…

I Lost My Baby Before I Was Even Grown—And Thought I’d Lost Everything, Until She Came Back.

I was seventeen when the boy I loved stepped backward out of my life. There wasn’t a dramatic fight. No slammed doors. No promises thrown like knives….