If you ask anyone who attended my wedding what they remember about it, they will not mention the venue, even though it had chandeliers like inverted crystal waterfalls and cost more than my first two cars combined. They will not mention the string quartet, or the centerpieces, or the way the late afternoon light turned the reception hall windows rose-gold at exactly the right moment.

They will tell you about my sister.

Specifically, they will tell you about the moment Madison stood up in her emerald bridesmaid dress, raised her champagne flute, and announced to two hundred guests that she was pregnant with my husband’s child. And then, if they are telling the story the way it deserves to be told, they will tell you what happened next.

But the night didn’t start with the scandal. It started with hope, the way most important nights do.

My name is Olivia Peterson, and I had been planning my wedding for fourteen months with the particular intensity of a woman who knows that the details matter and that no one else will care about them as much as she does. I had pinned things to inspiration boards at two in the morning. I had tasted seventeen varieties of cake frosting. I had changed my mind about the napkins three times, finally landing on ivory, which is not the same as champagne no matter what the venue coordinator tries to tell you.

When I stepped into that reception hall for the first time as Mrs. Peterson, my gown brushing the polished marble floor, Daniel’s fingers laced through mine, I felt something settle inside me that had been vibrating with tension for months. Not just the wedding tension, though there was plenty of that. Something deeper, older.

The room stood and cheered. My grandmother did her little shimmy, the one she reserved for weddings and bingo wins. Cameras flashed from every direction, strangers and cousins and my college roommate Jen who had already announced she was going to document everything on her phone.

Daniel squeezed my hand as we reached the head table, leaning close. “We made it,” he whispered, and I heard the weight he put into those three words, because we both knew they meant more than the obvious thing.

“We did,” I said back.

From my seat I could see the whole room laid out like a painting. My parents near the front, my father in his navy suit sitting exactly as upright as he always did, my mother already flushed with wine and sentiment. My cousins in the back, laughing too loud the way they always did. A table of children in their miniature formalwear, apparently conducting secret negotiations about the cake situation.

And Madison.

My sister sat just to my left at the head table, in a dress the precise shade of polished envy. Emerald, technically, but I had my own reading of that color by then. Her dark hair was pinned in a sleek chignon. Her lipstick was the aggressive red she wore when she wanted people to look at her, which was always, but especially tonight.

Madison was beautiful in the way that stops a room, with our mother’s cheekbones and a kind of deliberate glamour that made her feel like a main character wherever she went. Growing up alongside her, I had always felt softer by comparison, more approximate, as though someone had sketched me out while Madison had been rendered in high definition. People would stand in front of us and say things like “you’re both so pretty,” meaning it as a compliment and not realizing they were also delivering a ranking.

She had always needed to be the best. Not just to win, but to win against me specifically. Grades, friends, attention, relationships. It was never enough that she had something good; she needed mine to be lesser. Over the years I had watched her flirt with boys I liked in high school, undermine friendships, insert herself into moments that were supposed to be mine. Each time, I had told myself this was what sisters did, that underneath the competition there was love, that the core of it was unbreakable.

I kept believing that until she tried to break it on purpose.

The best man’s toast came first. Ethan, who had known Daniel since they were ten and had the easy, slightly rumpled warmth of a lifelong best friend, told a story about a camping trip that ended with a raccoon stealing their food and Daniel attempting to defend the camp with a cast-iron pan. It was exactly the right kind of speech: warm, silly, genuinely fond. The room laughed in the open way people laugh when they are comfortable and happy and want to stay that way.

I was still smiling when Ethan sat down.

Madison stood.

We hadn’t planned a toast from her. She had already fulfilled her role in the ceremony, had stood beside me and fixed my train and held my bouquet and smiled beautifully for every photograph. There was no reason for her to stand now. She stood anyway, and she moved with the particular deliberateness of someone who has practiced their entrance.

“I have an announcement,” she said.

The room quieted in stages. The string quartet stopped mid-phrase. Silverware was set down. A laugh in the back of the room trailed away like a question that suddenly realized it had no answer.